Logo image
  • BookDragon
  • About
  • The Blogger
  • Review Policy
  • Smithsonian APAC
 
45844
post-template-default,single,single-post,postid-45844,single-format-standard,stardust-core-1.1,stardust-child-theme-ver-1.0.0,stardust-theme-ver-3.1,ajax_updown_fade,page_not_loaded,smooth_scroll

BookDragon Blog

04 Oct / Open Borders: The Science and Ethics of Immigration by Bryan Caplan, illustrated by Zach Weinersmith [in Booklist]

*STARRED REVIEW
Borders, walls, detention camps, caged children … the dividing headlines seem never-ending. Regardless of readers’ immigration politics, economics professor Bryan Caplan (The Myth of the Rational Voter, 2008) will provoke: “Let’s put this in perspective,” he writes. “The world now produces about $75 trillion a year. Open borders would easily double this.” For eager naysayers, he’s ready with a comeback: “Why do math when you can hastily point fingers at foreigners?”

Beyond global prosperity, Caplan debunks protestations that opening borders will increase the financial burden on native populations (more working-age immigrants actually mean higher benefits with lower taxes); threats to safety (lightning is three times more likely to kill than terrorism); threats to culture and language (“cultural greatness” equals the opportunity to choose the best lifestyles, art, food, and more). He’s also got responses to every limiting political -ism, from egalitarism to Kantianism to utilitarianism. That his numbers-don’t-lie arguments are supported by comprehensive research – including 31 pages of source notes! – makes easy dismissal impossible.

His partner-in-insight Zach Weinersmith provides crisp, easy-to-grasp artistic support, with his own occasional insertions of humor (comical t-shirts, peanut gallery “duhs”) and pathos (a child’s beached corpse, a toddler in a “Don’t deport my mom” shirt). His dedication-page plea for information about a missing family member pointedly sets the stage for open borders.

Review: “Graphic Novels,” Booklist, September 15, 2019

Readers: Young Adult, Adult

Published: 2019

By Smithsonian Asian Pacific American Center in Adult Readers, Graphic Title/Manga/Manwha, Nonethnic-specific, Nonfiction, Repost, Young Adult Readers Tags > Assimilation, BookDragon, Booklist, Bryan Caplan, Haves vs. have-nots, Historical, Immigration, Open Borders, Refugees, Sociology, Zach Weinersmith
No Comment

Post a Comment
Cancel Reply

Smithsonian Institution
Asian Pacific American Center

Capital Gallery, Suite 7065
600 Maryland Avenue, SW
Washington, DC 20024

202.633.2691 | APAC@si.edu

Additional contact info

Mailing Address
Capital Gallery
Suite 7065, MRC: 516
P.O. Box 37012
Washington, DC 20013-7012

Fax: 202.633.2699

  • Facebook
  • Twitter
  • Instagram

SmithsonianAPA brings Asian Pacific American history, art, and culture to you through innovative museum experiences and digital initiatives.

About BookDragon

Welcome to BookDragon, filled with titles for the diverse reader. BookDragon is a new media initiative of the Smithsonian Asian Pacific American Center (APAC), and serves as a forum for those interested in learning more about the Asian Pacific American experience through literature. BookDragon is inhabited by Terry Hong.

Learn More

Contact BookDragon

Please email us at SIBookDragon@gmail.com

Follow BookDragon!
  • Twitter
  • Facebook

Looking for Something Else …?

or